Your iced coffee floats ready to eat - recipe for the float and homemade spiced creamer included

Iced Coffee Float Recipe

June 24, 2015 by Michelle

This shop has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and its advertiser. All opinions are mine alone. #SunsOutSpoonsOut #CollectiveBias
Iced coffee float recipe with a homemade spiced creamer bonus recipe

It’s hot, yo. As much as I complain about the cold weather during Chicago’s winters, I’m just as apt to complain about our hot and humid weather in the summer. Really, I need to have a biodome with my 76 and sunny, low humidity, with a light breeze, but that isn’t likely to happen anytime soon. That’s why I made an iced coffee float.

Even the guy on my thermometer agrees that summer is here and it’s time to cool down. I will admit, the cheekiness of his daily clothing does at least make me smile. Even in the winter when he’s bundled up with a coat, hat, scarf, and mittens. Today of course, he’s in his skivvies and sunglasses, and I’m pretty sure he’d take an iced coffee float if he could figure out how to get it in his hot little hands.

Cute thermometer measuring indoor and outdoor temps

With the wee ones heading to summer school for an 8am start (and two of their friends being dropped for carpool by 7am each day), I need my caffeine, but with the hot weather, I’ve made the switch from hot coffee to iced. Since I’m one of those who likes her coffee “doctored” (yum!), that means I’m making my creamer at home to add to my iced coffee. This time around, I made a spiced creamer that is amazing.

That said, I don’t go through enough creamer to use up my recipe before it goes bad, which is where making iced coffee comes in really handy. Why? I freeze my creamer and simply add the frozen creamer cubes to my coffee mug before the coffee, and voila! Best of all? The iced coffee doesn’t get watered down when it takes me awhile to drink because I’m running all over after children. I may or may not have patted myself on the back with this genius idea.

And? If you don’t have an ice cube tray (like me because – hello! – icemaker in my freezer), that doesn’t mean you can’t freeze your creamer into cubes. Simply use a mini muffin tray and fill it not quite to the top (so you don’t spill *cough*) and freeze them for a couple hours, then run the bottom of your tin under warm water for a few seconds – literally just a few seconds as they’ll melt again quickly – and pop them out. Store them in a zip top bag in your freezer to keep them good for up to two months, but mine never last that long!

Slide creamer cubes into your freezer

I’ve been enjoying my iced coffee this way, but the other day when I was picking up some more sweetened condensed milk at Walmart to make my creamer, the were having a Blue Bunny ice cream demo with the vanilla bean flavor. A lightbulb went off in my head, and suddenly my iced coffee turned into an iced coffee float.

Blue Bunny ice cream at Walmart

That isn’t exactly how they were doing the demo in my Walmart, of course. Instead, they served our ice cream in a little cup. They also had some fresh apricot cut up, so I asked nicely, and they let me put a slice of the apricot in my cup. yum! There are more demos of Blue Bunny ice cream coming up over the Fourth of July where they’re partnering with Chips Ahoy for that set of demos. Cookies? Apricots? It’s all good!


I’m so glad it was a Blue Bunny demo that was my inspiration, too. You know I try to be careful about some of the ingredients I serve my family, and this was a great reminder for me that Blue Bunny makes their ice cream the same way I do. All that’s in it? Cream, milk, sugar, egg, and vanilla. Perfect! This is exactly what I needed to make my morning iced coffee an afternoon iced coffee float.

Blue Bunny ice cream ingredents

Granted, I switch to decaf to make the iced coffee float because I’m enjoying it in the afternoon instead of the morning (or so I’m telling you!). I also use “just” one of the homemade spiced creamers instead of two for the ice coffee float because the ice cream adds the rest of the sweetness and creaminess that I’m looking for.

Your iced coffee floats ready to eat - recipe for the float and homemade spiced creamer included

I made one for me and one for my husband (who drinks his coffee black or with just a little milk usually), and he gulped the entire thing down before I could get a single photo. I think that means he liked it. I enjoy savoring my iced coffee float, however.

Enjoying my iced coffee float

His iced coffee float was straight espresso, with the creamer and Blue Bunny vanilla bean ice cream, while I did more of the cafe americano version by adding some water to my shot of espresso before topping it with my Blue Bunny scoop. So easy and so delicious, this was the perfect summer treat for us. In fact, this may become the featured drink for my next barbecue – how fun would that be? Easy prep I can do ahead of time and then wow my guests? Love it!

Blue Bunny iced coffee floats featuring homemade spiced creamer

Iced Coffee Float Recipe

(and homemade spiced creamer)

Personally, I like making my own creamer. I know exactly what’s in it, and I can flavor it any way I want. This super simple spiced creamer is my current favorite, and I love that it’s something that isn’t commercially available, too.

To make it, you need a can of sweetened condensed milk, regular milk, cinnamon, nutmeg, vanilla, and almond extract. It’s amazing how this tastes, and this recipe makes twenty-four frozen cubes for your iced coffee float making with a little extra so you can enjoy some right away, too. I store my extra in a mason jar that’s easy to shake up before using and then pour into my coffee, just make sure it’s tightly sealed and kept in your fridge.

Store ice cubes in a zip top bag

To make the creamer, add the sweetened condensed milk and regular milk to a heavy saucepan. You want to heat this up just a tiny bit so that it incorporates well without actually cooking it. Simply stir it together, and once the two milks are one homogeneous mixture, turn off your heat. You could make this off the stove by shaking it, but I prefer this method to ensure I have no lumps at all.

Add milk to sweetened condensed milk

Add the cinnamon, nutmeg, vanilla, and almond extract. To get the cinnamon to incorporate into the creamer, go ahead and use a whisk (or me with my handy dandy aerolatte frothing tool) to get it all in there. The cinnamon will resist a bit, but keep at it and it will get mixed in there enough to provide the flavor you’re looking for.

Add nutmeg to spiced creamer

From there, I like to pour my creamer into my liquid measuring cup so that I can pour cleanly and not make (as much of) a mess. It’s another of those ideas where you go “duh” but just don’t think about most of the time.

Tips to make your creamer in the freezer

Simply pour your creamer either into your ice cube tray if you have one or your mini muffin tin if you’re like me and don’t. Fill them not quite to the top so nothing spills when you’re placing it in the freezer.

Pour spiced creamer into tin not quite to the top

Freeze, pop them out, and store in a zip top bag until you’re ready to use them. This doesn’t take long to freeze, less than two hours, so there isn’t too much delayed gratification when you want your iced coffee float. Once your homemade creamer is frozen, you’re ready to assemble your iced coffee float.

For the coffee, feel free to make your favorite kind whether it’s the espresso pot on the stove like we do or the single cup machine or anything in between. That allows you to determine the strength you want, perfect for my strong coffee loving husband and wimpy me. Once your coffee is made, remove your frozen creamer cubes and place them in the bottom of your cup.

Add frozen creamer cubes to your cup

Pour your coffee over the creamer cube, letting it melt and cool your coffee at the same time. If you’re using espresso, dilute as needed. Make sure you leave room at the top for your ice cream, but you want this most of the way full, leaving a couple inches clearance.

Add coffee to your cup

Now it’s time to turn that iced coffee into an iced coffee float. Pull out your Blue Bunny vanilla bean ice cream, and scoop up a beautiful ball of yum.

Add Blue Bunny Ice Cream to finish your iced coffee float

Carefully place the scoop of ice cream into your iced coffee and watch it start to melt and make your iced coffee float creamy and even more delicious. Add a straw, and you’re ready to go.

Make your iced coffee float truly float

Iced Coffee Float and Homemade Spiced Creamer

Iced Coffee Float and Homemade Spiced Creamer


    For the Spiced Creamer
  • 14 oz can sweetened condensed milk
  • 1 1/2 c milk
  • 2 t cinnamon
  • 1/4 t nutmeg
  • 1 t almond extract
  • 1 t vanilla
  • For the Iced Coffee Float
  • 1 creamer cube
  • 1 c hot coffee
  • 1 scoop Blue Bunny vanilla bean ice cream


  1. To make the creamer, add the milk and the sweetened condensed milk to a heavy saucepan and turn the heat on low. You want this to warm up just enough to come together but not actually cook anything.
  2. Add the cinnamon, nutmeg, almond extract, and vanilla. Whisk together until the cinnamon is mostly incorporated.
  3. Pour the creamer into ice cube trays or mini muffin tin cups. Freeze for two hours.
  4. Run the bottom under warm water for a few seconds, then pop the creamer cubes from the container. Store in a zip top bag in the freezer for up to two months.
  5. To make the float, place a creamer cube in the bottom of a cup. Pour your coffee over the creamer cube. Scoop ice cream into the top of the mug and serve immediately.

I’m so in love with this iced coffee float. What are you doing with your Blue Bunny ice cream this summer?

Shares 0


  • Choya

    I love love LOVE Iced coffee’s, I am gonna have to try this recipe.

    • Michelle

      I do, too, Choya. Especially when they’re ummmm flavored. This was sooo yummy – I hope you like it 🙂

  • Carolyn West

    This is so great. It’s like a grown up milkshake. I need to go back to Walmart and get more Blue Bunny and try these. I can’t ever keep ice cream in my house with 3 kids. #client

  • Maria Magdalena

    I like it. Thank you for linking up to Creative K Kids’ Tasty Tuesdays. I have pinned your post to our Tasty Tuesdays Pinterest Board.

  • Jenn

    I love iced coffees, and my stove top espresso pot makes 6 cups (so I refrigerate what I don’t use for a day or two.) I’ve never tried to make my own creamer, I’ll have to give this a shot!

Leave a Comment

Your email is never shared.
Required fields are marked *